She and her family moved to Notre Dame du Rosaire, Quebec about 1883, then to Bay City, Michigan in 1890 ®3274 where the family lived at 808 Monroe Street. ®3274 She could read, write and speak English in 1900. ®3274 In 1900 she moved with her mother and siblings to Bayfield, Wisconsin. On 10 August 1911 she wrote a postcard from Duluth, Minnesota. She was married and lived in Virginia, Minnesota when her father died on 11 June 1908. ®3277On 1 Nov 1918 and 15 Aug 1919 she lived at 106 7th Street, Virginia, Minnesota. In 1930 she was 45 and lived with Aili, 24, Elaine, 4, and Corinne, 1 year and 3 months with her brother-in-laws family, Howard West, in Virginia, Minnesota. Her husband, Barney, did not live with them. ®3912 She lived "out west” when she visited Bayfield from 14 June to 24 June 1935. ®162 She lived at Box 33, Hines, Oregon in 1946, 1951 and 1962. ®3954 She lived in Hines, Oregon at the time of her mother’s death on 4 February 1951.

How could this be true? “She and her family moved to Notre Dame du Rosaire, Quebec about 1883” She and several siblings were baptized at parish Notre Dame in Laterriere, near Chicoutimi, while Notre Dame du Rosaire is south of Quebec City.